The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has proposed a new rule that would require employers to pay additional fees when extending the H-1B and L-1 visas for foreign workers. This would expand the application of the existing 9/11 Response and Biometric Entry-Exit Fee, which is currently applied only to initial visa petitions or changes of employer.
Under the proposed rule, employers who are required to pay the fee for initial or change-of-employer petitions would also need to pay:
- $4,000 for H-1B visa extensions
- $4,500 for L-1 visa extensions
Background on the 9/11 Response Fee
This fee was introduced as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2016 to fund national security initiatives, particularly the biometric entry-exit system used to track the movement of non-U.S. citizens. The fee currently applies to employers with 50 or more employees in the U.S., with more than 50% of those employees on H-1B or L-1 visas.
Reasons for the Change
DHS argues that the expansion of the fee to cover extensions is necessary to:
- Increase Funding: Additional revenue is required to sustain and improve the biometric entry-exit system, which is essential for tracking immigration and ensuring national security.
- Consistency and Fairness: The change would create a more uniform application of the fee across all petition types, ensuring that employers contribute equally, regardless of whether the petition is for a new hire or an extension.
- Enhanced Security: The funding will support enhanced national security measures, such as monitoring and managing immigration.
Impact on Employers
The proposed rule would significantly increase costs for employers, especially those who rely heavily on H-1B and L-1 visa holders. Companies with a large number of employees on these visas may face a financial burden when seeking to extend their workers’ visas. This could prompt employers to reconsider their approach to hiring foreign workers or extending their visas.
Next Steps
DHS is currently accepting public comments on the proposed rule. The comment period will end on July 8, 2024, after which DHS will consider feedback and decide whether to finalize the rule.
If implemented, this change could affect many companies, especially those in sectors that heavily depend on foreign workers, such as tech, engineering, and healthcare.
Impact on Employers
How Fee Increases Could Affect Companies Hiring Foreign Talent
The increase in visa fees is expected to have a substantial financial impact on companies that rely on foreign workers. For instance, the application fee for H-1B petitions will rise from $460 to $780, representing a 70% increase. This hike can significantly affect overall hiring costs, especially for organizations that frequently sponsor skilled foreign workers.
Potential Challenges for Small Businesses vs. Larger Corporations
- Small Businesses: Smaller companies may struggle more with the increased costs due to limited budgets. The higher fees could deter them from hiring foreign talent, which may be crucial for their growth and competitiveness.
- Larger Corporations: While larger corporations might absorb the increased costs more easily, they may still face challenges in budgeting for immigration expenses. The cumulative effect of higher fees across multiple applications can lead to significant financial implications.
Sectoral Impacts (e.g., Tech, Healthcare)
Different sectors will experience varying impacts from the fee increases:
- Tech Industry: The tech sector heavily relies on H-1B visas to fill specialized roles. Increased costs may lead companies to reconsider their hiring strategies or invest more in domestic talent development.
- Healthcare Sector: Hospitals and healthcare providers that depend on foreign-trained professionals may face staffing shortages if they cannot afford the increased sponsorship costs.
Impact on Visa Applicants
Financial Burden on Employees and Their Families
The fee increases create a financial burden for individuals seeking visas:
- Increased Application Costs: Applicants must now budget for higher fees not only for their visa applications but also for associated costs like legal fees.
- Family Considerations: For those applying with family members under derivative visas, the cumulative cost can be substantial, potentially discouraging families from pursuing opportunities in the U.S.
Changes in Accessibility for Individuals from Less Affluent Backgrounds
The increased fees may disproportionately affect individuals from less affluent backgrounds:
- Barriers to Entry: Higher application costs could limit access to U.S. opportunities for talented individuals who cannot afford the new fees.
- Impact on Diversity: This could reduce diversity within industries that benefit from international talent, as underrepresented groups may face greater challenges in accessing immigration pathways.
Potential Deterrent Effects on International Talent
The overall increase in costs could deter international talent from pursuing opportunities in the U.S.:
- Comparative Disadvantage: As other countries offer more affordable pathways for skilled workers, the U.S. risks losing its competitive edge in attracting top talent.
Industry Reactions
Statements from Industry Leaders and Advocacy Groups
Industry leaders have expressed concern over the fee increases:
- Tech Industry Advocacy: Organizations like TechNet have voiced opposition to the changes, arguing that they could hinder innovation by making it harder to hire skilled workers.
Opinions from Legal Experts and Immigration Consultants
Legal experts warn that increased fees may complicate hiring processes:
- Complexity of Compliance: Immigration consultants note that higher costs could lead employers to cut back on sponsorships or seek alternative solutions, complicating compliance with immigration laws.
Employer Responses to Potential Fee Increases
Employers are beginning to strategize around these changes:
- Budget Adjustments: Many companies are reassessing their immigration budgets and considering how best to manage increased costs while still attracting skilled talent.
Broader Immigration Policy Context
How This Proposal Fits into Broader Trends in U.S. Immigration Policy
The fee increases are part of a broader trend toward tightening immigration policies:
- Cost Recovery Measures: USCIS has indicated that these fee hikes are necessary to cover operational costs and improve processing times amid increasing application volumes.
Connection with Other Recent Changes to Visa Programs
These changes align with other recent adjustments in U.S. immigration policy aimed at regulating entry:
- Increased Scrutiny: There has been a general trend toward more stringent scrutiny of visa applications, which could be exacerbated by rising fees.
Alternatives to Fee Increases
Suggestions from Stakeholders for Alternative Funding Mechanisms
Stakeholders have proposed alternatives to mitigate the impact of fee increases:
- Government Funding: Advocates suggest that Congress should allocate more funding to USCIS rather than relying solely on application fees.
- Sliding Scale Fees: Implementing a sliding scale based on company size or applicant income could help make visa applications more accessible.
Criticisms of the Proposal and Advocacy for Reform
Critics argue that increased fees disproportionately affect those who already face barriers:
- Calls for Reform: Advocacy groups are pushing for reforms that prioritize accessibility and fairness within the immigration system rather than imposing additional financial burdens.
The recent announcement of visa fee increases presents significant challenges for both employers and applicants navigating the U.S. immigration landscape. While these changes aim to support USCIS operations and improve processing times, they also raise concerns about accessibility and competitiveness in attracting international talent. As stakeholders respond to these developments, it is essential to explore alternative funding mechanisms and advocate for reforms that ensure a fairer immigration process for all individuals seeking opportunities in the United States.
How Law and Visas Can Help?
At Law and Visas, our team of expert immigration consultants is here to make your travel to the US straightforward and successful. Whether you’re applying for a Green Card, Visitor Visa, or Study Visa, we handle every step from preparing your application to gathering the required documents.
Our immigration Consultants and Lawyers ensure that your application meets the highest standards, with no details missed. We’ll also keep you informed throughout the process and coordinate with the immigration office or embassy on your behalf.
Law and Visas has a strong record of helping clients secure the visas/permits they need in the US. Call us today at +234 812 5505 986 to learn how we can assist you.
