For the first time since the creation of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program on June 15, 2012, the majority of undocumented high school graduates in the U.S. are now ineligible for the program. This shift is due to the requirement that applicants must have arrived in the U.S. before June 15, 2007, a condition that many recent graduates no longer meet.
The Impact of DACA’s Eligibility Rules on Recent Graduates
According to a new report from FWD.us, approximately 100,000 undocumented students graduate from U.S. high schools each year. In addition, about 600,000 students are currently enrolled in K-12 schools across the country. Despite these large numbers, only about one-quarter of the 2022 high school graduates would qualify for DACA. The primary reason for this is the program’s strict age and arrival date requirements, which mandate that applicants must have entered the U.S. before June 15, 2007.
This issue is expected to persist, with an estimated 100,000 undocumented students graduating each year over the next several years. However, the proportion of these students who are eligible for DACA—and therefore able to work legally in the U.S.—is expected to shrink over time, further limiting opportunities for many undocumented young people.
DACA Under Legal Challenge
The DACA program has faced increasing uncertainty in recent years. Currently, the program is under legal review at the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, following a decision by a federal judge in 2021 to block the approval of new DACA applications. In 2017, the Trump administration attempted to end DACA altogether, which set off a series of legal battles that have left the program in a state of limbo.
In response to this legal uncertainty, the Biden administration is working to overturn the court’s decision and allow new applications to be processed. The next major step in the case is a hearing on July 6, 2022, where oral arguments will be presented at the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. The administration is also pushing forward with a new rule to codify DACA, which was proposed in September 2021 and is expected to be finalized before the November 2022 midterm elections.
The Effects of DACA’s Legal Uncertainty on Recipients
Even with the efforts to protect and preserve DACA, the ongoing legal uncertainty has had a noticeable impact on current DACA recipients. According to reports, DACA recipients have experienced a 15% drop in their feelings of integration and inclusion within U.S. society from 2020 to 2021. The prolonged legal battles and lack of clarity about the program’s future have caused anxiety and stress for the 2.8 million estimated “Dreamers”—undocumented individuals who came to the U.S. as children—living in the country.
Educational Barriers for Undocumented Graduates Without DACA
Undocumented students who graduate from high school face significant educational challenges, particularly if they are ineligible for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. These barriers can severely limit their opportunities for higher education and future employment, creating a cycle of disadvantage that affects both undergraduate and graduate students.
Ineligibility for Financial Support
One of the most pressing issues for undocumented graduates without DACA is their inability to access federal student loans and financial aid. DACA provides certain protections and access to resources that undocumented students lack, leaving them vulnerable when it comes to funding their education.
- Student Loans: Without DACA, undocumented students cannot qualify for federal student loans, which are often essential for financing higher education. This lack of access forces many to rely on private loans, which may have higher interest rates and stricter repayment terms.
- Scholarships: Many scholarships specifically exclude undocumented students or require DACA status as a prerequisite. As a result, these graduates miss out on critical funding opportunities that could help alleviate the financial burden of college tuition.
These financial barriers disproportionately affect both undergraduate and graduate students, limiting their ability to pursue advanced degrees or specialized training that could enhance their career prospects.
Impact on Educational Attainment
The inability to secure financial aid often results in lower enrollment rates among undocumented graduates in higher education institutions. Many are forced to work multiple jobs to support themselves while attending school, which can detract from their academic performance and overall college experience.
- Undergraduate Students: The pressure of financial instability can lead many undocumented undergraduates to drop out before completing their degrees. According to studies, a significant percentage of undocumented students express the desire to continue their education but are hindered by financial constraints.
- Graduate Students: For those who manage to enroll in graduate programs, the lack of funding can limit research opportunities and networking events essential for career advancement. Graduate education often requires substantial financial investment, making it even more challenging for undocumented students without DACA.
DACA and Its Expanding Eligibility Requirements
Since its introduction in 2012 under the Obama administration, DACA has undergone various changes regarding eligibility requirements. Initially designed to protect young undocumented immigrants from deportation and provide work authorization, the program has seen its criteria evolve over time.
Changes in Eligibility
- Initial Criteria: When DACA was first implemented, eligible individuals had to meet specific criteria, including arriving in the U.S. before age 16 and being under 31 years old as of June 15, 2012.
- Subsequent Changes: Under different presidential administrations, eligibility requirements have tightened or expanded. For instance, during the Trump administration, efforts were made to rescind DACA altogether, leading to uncertainty among potential applicants. Conversely, the Biden administration has sought to restore protections and expand eligibility but has faced legal challenges.
These changes have directly impacted undocumented graduates’ ability to benefit from DACA protections. Many who graduated after 2020 find themselves ineligible due to stricter criteria or changes in policy interpretation.
The Effect of DACA Ineligibility on Mental Health
The psychological toll of being an undocumented graduate without access to DACA protections can be profound. The uncertainty surrounding their immigration status creates significant mental health challenges.
Psychological Stressors
- Anxiety and Uncertainty: Many undocumented graduates experience chronic anxiety about their future prospects. The fear of deportation or being unable to secure stable employment can lead to overwhelming stress.
- Isolation: Ineligibility for DACA can also lead to feelings of isolation from peers who may not share similar challenges. This sense of exclusion can exacerbate mental health issues like depression and anxiety.
Support systems are crucial for these individuals; however, many may not have access to adequate mental health resources due to their immigration status or financial constraints.
State-Specific Solutions for Undocumented Graduates
Some states have implemented policies aimed at supporting undocumented graduates who cannot access DACA protections. These state-level solutions offer alternatives that help bridge the gap left by federal policies.
Examples of State-Level Support
- In-State Tuition: States like California and Texas allow undocumented students to pay in-state tuition rates at public colleges and universities, making higher education more accessible.
- State-Funded Financial Aid: Some states provide state-funded scholarships or financial aid programs specifically for undocumented students. For instance, New York offers the Excelsior Scholarship program that allows eligible undocumented students to receive tuition-free education at public colleges.
- Local Support Systems: Community organizations often play a vital role in providing resources such as mentorship programs, legal assistance, and workshops focused on navigating college applications and financial aid processes.
These state-specific initiatives demonstrate a commitment to supporting undocumented graduates despite federal limitations.
Advocacy and Legal Support for DACA Ineligible Graduates
Advocacy groups and legal organizations play a critical role in assisting undocumented graduates who cannot access DACA protections. These entities provide essential resources and guidance throughout the complex immigration landscape.
Role of Advocacy Groups
- Legal Guidance: Nonprofits specializing in immigration law offer free or low-cost legal services to help undocumented individuals understand their rights and options.
- Educational Resources: Many organizations provide workshops and informational sessions aimed at helping undocumented students navigate educational pathways despite their status.
- Community Support: Advocacy groups often foster community networks that connect individuals with similar experiences, offering emotional support and practical advice on addressing common challenges faced by undocumented graduates.
Alternatives to DACA for Undocumented Graduates
For those who are ineligible for DACA, exploring alternative pathways is essential for securing legal status or enhancing educational opportunities.
Potential Alternatives
- Family-Sponsored Immigration Visas: Undocumented graduates may explore options for family-sponsored immigration if they have relatives who are U.S. citizens or lawful permanent residents willing to sponsor them.
- The DREAM Act: Although it has not yet passed into law, advocacy continues around proposed legislation like the DREAM Act that would create a pathway to citizenship for eligible undocumented youth through education or military service.
- Employment-Based Immigration Pathways: Depending on individual circumstances, some may qualify for employment-based visas if they secure job offers from employers willing to sponsor them.
By understanding these alternatives, undocumented graduates can better navigate their options outside of DACA protections.
The Role of Employers in Supporting Undocumented Graduates
Employers play a crucial role in supporting undocumented graduates, particularly those who are ineligible for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. While DACA provides some protections and work authorization, many undocumented graduates find themselves without these benefits. However, proactive employers can still create opportunities and provide resources to help these individuals thrive in the workforce.
Proactive Hiring Practices
Many companies and industries have recognized the potential of undocumented graduates and are actively seeking to hire them. Businesses in sectors such as technology, hospitality, and agriculture often prioritize skills over immigration status, understanding that diverse teams lead to innovation and growth. For instance, companies like Google and Starbucks have publicly stated their commitment to hiring diverse talent, including undocumented individuals. Employers can also implement inclusive hiring practices by clearly stating in job postings that they welcome applications from all qualified candidates, regardless of immigration status. This transparency helps undocumented graduates feel more confident applying for positions that may otherwise seem out of reach.
Providing Resources for Employment Authorization
In addition to hiring undocumented graduates, employers can assist them in obtaining alternative work visas or employment authorization. Many undocumented individuals may not be aware of the pathways available to them. Employers can support their employees by:
- Offering Visa Sponsorship: Some employers are willing to sponsor undocumented graduates for employment-based visas. This process typically involves labor certification (PERM), where the employer must demonstrate that there are no qualified U.S. workers available for the position.
- Connecting Employees with Legal Resources: Employers can partner with immigration attorneys or organizations that specialize in helping undocumented individuals navigate their immigration options. Providing access to legal assistance can empower employees to explore potential pathways to legal status.
Importance of Comprehensive Immigration Reform
While employer support is vital, it is essential to advocate for comprehensive immigration reform that addresses the broader needs of undocumented graduates. The limitations of DACA highlight the need for a more permanent solution that creates pathways to legal status and employment for all undocumented individuals. Comprehensive immigration reform could benefit both undocumented graduates and the U.S. economy by:
- Filling Labor Gaps: Many industries face labor shortages, and allowing undocumented graduates to work legally would help fill these gaps while contributing to economic growth.
- Enhancing Workforce Stability: By providing a clear pathway to legal status, comprehensive reform would enable undocumented graduates to invest in their education and careers without the fear of deportation or job loss.
As DACA faces a critical moment in its legal history, its future remains uncertain. The program has been a lifeline for many young undocumented immigrants, allowing them to work legally and access essential services. However, with each passing year, more high school graduates are missing out on the opportunity to apply, leaving fewer pathways to legal employment and stability for future generations.
How Law and Visas Can Help?
At Law and Visas, our team of expert immigration consultants is here to make your travel to the U.S. straightforward and successful. Whether you’re applying for a U Visa or a T Visa, we handle every step—from preparing your application to gathering the required documents.
Our Immigration Consultants and Lawyers ensure that your application meets the highest standards, with no details missed. We’ll also keep you informed throughout the process and coordinate with the immigration office or embassy on your behalf.
Law and Visas has a strong record of helping clients secure the visas/permits they need to visit the United States. You can call us today at +234 812 5505 986 to learn how we can help you.
